Answer
The only time they ask for another one is if the original card on file has expired, been cancelled, lost or stolen. Otherwise, you only need one card. The likely reason for this is that during the set up process Lyft was unable to verify the card with your bank.
Add a New Card in Lyft app
HOW TO USE LYFT RIDESHARE WITHOUT A CREDIT CARD!!!
Why is LYFT asking for a new card?
The only time they ask for another one is if the original card on file has expired, been cancelled, lost or stolen. Otherwise, you only need one card. The likely reason for this is that during the set up process Lyft was unable to verify the card with your bank.